Reviews from the London theatre critics are coming in for Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle, now playing at the West End’s Apollo Theatre in London.

The comedy magic show is playing in London through March and April 2024 at the Apollo Theatre, before going on a UK tour.

The Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle cast features original company members Henry Lewis and Jonathan Sayer.

Produced by Mischief, the creators of long-running West End farce The Play That Goes Wrong, Mind Mangler recently played on Broadway at New World Stages, and first made its premiere at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival in 2022.

The premise of the show is that magician “Mind Mangler” is returning to the stage following a disappointing two-night run at the Scranton, PA Holiday Inn Conference Center, suite 2B. His new two-man show solo spectacular is predicted to spiral into chaos as he attempts to read your MIND…

Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle is directed by Hannah Sharkey, with set design by Sara Perks, costume design by Roberto Surace, lighting design by David Howe, sound design by Helen Skiera, and video design by Gillian Tan. Ben Hart serves as magic consultant, Steve Brown is the composer, and Tom Nickson is the U.K. production manager. Lucas McMahon is the U.S. Executive Producer.

The show is based on a character originally created in Magic Goes Wrong by Penn Jillette, Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, Henry Shields and Teller. The US company also includes Bartley Booz and Brandon James Ellis.

Read reviews from TimeOut, The Times and more, with further reviews to be added.

Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle is playing at the Apollo Theatre until 28 April 2024.

Book tickets to Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle in London – and the UK tour


What are the critics saying about Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle?

The Times

"A joyful spinoff from Magic Goes Wrong"

"... Mind Mangler is a joyful spin-off show for the shabby, malfunctioning mentalist first seen in Magic Goes Wrong. It is a comedy at the expense of his sort of sub-Derren Brown illusionist. It also triumphs at the illusions of which it first affects to be incapable."

"The key here is Henry Lewis’s Orson Wellesian pseudo-gravitas as Mind Mangler, a dignity forever upended by his circumstances, temper or rebellious associates. “Don’t pity me!” he roars as the audience try to help him find a solution."

"Hannah Sharkey’s pacey production gives several neat twists on the expected, never better than in a spoon-bending routine that is both a good joke and a fine spectacle."

"It will be too broad for some tastes. Yet the surprises and laughs keep coming in a spin-off that’s less varied but more consistent than the show from which it sprang."

Dominic Maxwell, The Times
Read the review
More reviews by Dominic Maxwell
More The Times reviews
The Stage
★★★

"Nods to classic comedies"

"Mischief Theatre’s latest is silly, predictable but unarguably funny"

"Once we are comfortably in a rhythm of watching the Mind Mangler’s strained attempts to manipulate his audience and read their minds, it’s an eerie curveball when his tricks start going right."

"But this is a play, not a magic show, even if the plot is thin. Called on stage multiple times is Sayer as the Stooge, a planted audience member and the Mind Mangler’s incompetent aid. The pair are housemates in a struggling bromance and the story, which has a few ‘aww’ moments, sees them patching up their relationship."

"Fortunately, it is funny. Even if the humour outstrips the magic and the story doesn’t develop, Mischief prove there is still more mileage in their it-won’t-be-all-right-on-the-night yarn, as silly and predictable as it may be."

Holly O'Mahony, The Stage
Read the review
More The Stage reviews
TimeOut

"Mischief Theatre’s unnecessary sequel to ‘Magic Goes Wrong’ beats you over the head with the same joke for over two hours"

"As is customary in the plays created by Lewis and his co-writers Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, there’s mess and slapstick aplenty. But, is two hours-plus of slip-ups and mistakes enough to keep our attention? Well, most of the audience seems to love it."

Eventually, the show pulls the rug from underneath us. Shockingly, the Mind Mangler’s tricks start to go right. His successful and genuinely very impressive mind reading sends ‘oohs’ and ‘ahhs’ around the audience, while the big finale is would surely make Derren Brown impressed. But it’s a little too late to compensate for the sloggy bulk of the play. You’d get more from a night out at a decent actual magic show."

Anya Ryan, TimeOut
Read the review
More reviews by Anya Ryan
More TimeOut reviews
Average Rating: 3 Stars based on 1 reviews
CriticScore: 60 based on 1 reviews
Sign-up for booking alerts, offers & news about Mind Mangler: Member of the Tragic Circle and other shows:

Main photo: Mind Mangler West End 2024 - Henry Lewis. Photo by Pamela Raith

Related News

See all

Latest News

See all